• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Sam's Pizza Shop: Hidden Gem for Authentic Pizza in Canonsburg

Nestled beside the Sarris Chocolate factory in Canonsburg, PA, Sam’s Pizza Shop is a hidden gem that delights both locals and visitors. This cozy eatery is renowned for its delicious square pizzas, crafted with a homemade sauce that impresses upon first bite. Patrons rave about the welcoming atmosphere and the dedication of owner Dave, who ensures every order meets high standards of quality. With its cash-only policy and a simple, nostalgic vibe reminiscent of childhood pizza days, Sam's focuses on delivering comfort food in a friendly setting. Come savor a slice, and you'll quickly see why many keep returning for more.

Sam's Pizza Shop at a glance

  • Address 525 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA 15317, United States
  • Phone +1 724-745-9861
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Sam's Pizza Shop: Reviews & Ratings

Paige Luellen
5

Truly the NICEST people running/working in the shop! Everyone was so sweet and welcoming when I picked up my delivery nearing closing time. I simply had to leave a review based on my two minutes of meeting them. Pizza is top notch. It is cash only so come prepared!

Robin OConnor
5

I was surprised how much I loved this pizza! it’s a little hidden gem in Canonsburg next to Sarris Chocolate factory. The crust was really good, sauce is good, toppings were good. I’ll be back for sure!

Ninja Charles
5

Reminds me of my elementary school pizza El pres needs to come down for a review 9.8

P.J. V.
5

A Canonsburg hidden pizza gem. 5 star for a different homemade pizza located right next to Sarris candy. Square pizza, sauce and crust above average well done with good hand cut cheese. Dave the owner takes the orders and makes sure you are well pleased. Can’t eat there and to go only. Dave says come back, we will

Jamie Huber'Gronka
4

Nice friendly hole in the wall. Wish the pizza options were explained better. Basically, 1 slice is 1.19. A topping is .30 . No one explained what a tray was. So, we ordered a cheese and a pepperoni. The tray of pepperoni was 41.46. Cause 28 slices of pizza, .30 a topping, pepperoni on each piece, and so on. Still with me? However, as confusing as it was. $70 for 56 squares of pizza is not bad, lol. The homeade sauce was exceptional. I continued care for the crust, but the kids thought it was fine. Could have been cooked longer and more cheese, but overall, it was a nice find. The building reminded me of when I was a kid, pure nostalgia.

Drewsky McGillicuddy
5

Got off the highway looking for Grandpa Joe's got lost and went back to 1978... Which is funny because I was in town for a convention for a movie.That was filmed in 1978. I pretty much love everything about this place. The owners were real life human beings that you kind of want to just stay and hang out with. They've got pinball and an arcade machine for you while you wait. I've literally never seen pizza prepared the way they do it. I feel like i've also never tasted pizza quite like this. The cheese, crust, and sauce almost tasted like dipping grilled cheese and tomato soup. I will definitely be back through on my way back up to pittsburgh next year.

Susan McNiff
4

Very good pizza. I love the square pizza.

Location

  • Sam's Pizza Shop
    Sam's Pizza Shop
    525 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA 15317, United States Hotline: +1 724-745-9861

Welcome to Sam's Pizza Shop, a delightful hidden gem nestled at 525 Adams Ave, Canonsburg, PA. This cozy pizzeria effortlessly combines a warm, inviting atmosphere with top-notch pizza offerings that keep customers coming back for more. With its convenient location near the iconic Sarris Chocolate factory, it’s an easy stop for both pizza lovers and sweet tooths alike.

From the moment you step inside, you will be greeted by the friendly faces of the staff who truly embody the spirit of hospitality. As one enthusiastic customer, Paige Luellen, noted, the team at Sam's Pizza Shop are "the NICEST people running/working in the shop!" Their welcoming demeanor makes picking up your pizza an experience worth sharing.

The menu features a variety of pizzas with standout qualities. Customers rave about the homey appeal of the square pizzas, noting that the crust is well-executed and the toppings are fresh and delicious. Robin OConnor describes it perfectly as a “little hidden gem” where “the crust was really good, sauce is good, toppings were good.” For those seeking a nostalgic flavor, Ninja Charles expressed that the pizza reminded him of the blissful days of elementary school pizza, giving it a stellar rating of 9.8 out of 10.

One of the unique aspects of Sam's Pizza Shop is its cash-only policy, which encourages patrons to come prepared. Although, as Jamie Huber Gronka humorously recounts, understanding the order options can lead to surprising totals, the affordability of the pizza is hard to overlook. With 56 squares of pizza for just $70, you're getting a hearty meal for a great value! And let’s not forget the exceptional homemade sauce, which customers consistently praise for enhancing the overall pizza experience.

Overall, whether you're a local or just passing through, Sam's Pizza Shop promises a delightful slice of nostalgia that's carefully crafted with love. Not only is the pizza worth the stop, but it's the genuine interaction with the staff that makes the experience memorable. So, grab your cash and prepare for a flavorful adventure, because Sam’s Pizza Shop is ready to welcome you with open arms and a fresh, delicious pizza!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Does not have assistive hearing loop
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Cash only
    • Accepts cheques